Holidays Kind To Some Retailers, Stingy To Others
January 10, 2005,
New York — The all-important Christmas selling season turned out to be a mixed bag for key U.S. retailers despite the predictable 11th-hour surge as shoppers sought out bargains, and the strongest results came from the extreme ends of the retailing spectrum — luxury goods and off-price.
At the other end of the spectrum, the three big warehouse operators all turned in a strong performance, with Costco up 9 percent; BJ's up 5.6 percent; and Sam's up 5.4 percent.
Off-pricers turned in a strong performance, led by rocket-hot Stein Mart at a 10.3 percent gain, followed by TJX with a 6 percent increase.
Among full-price, mainstream retailers, only The Bon-Ton finished strongly, with a 6.6 percent increase. And sales would have risen even higher but for winter storms which closed some Elder-Beerman stores in Indiana, Ohio and Kentucky in the days leading up to Christmas.
Among the nation's discounters, Target recorded the biggest increase, with a 5.1 percent gain. Wal-Mart Stores came in with a moderate 2.6 percent gain. But helped by the strong performance at Sam's, all of Wal-Mart Stores Inc. came in at the high end of its forecast range with a 3 percent increase.
Once past The Bon-Ton with its hefty 6.6 percent increase, department stores' performance was mixed. Saks Department Store Group came in with a 2.8 percent gain, and Federated was up 2.3 percent. Dillard's was virtually flat, inching up 0.8 percent.
Notably weak performances among department stores were turned in by May, down 3.5 percent, Sears down 3 percent and JCPenney, slipping 1.2 percent.
Junior department store Kohl's came in with a robust 3.1 percent increase, recovering from weakness early in 2004 and during 2003.
Looking ahead to January, and the promotional close to the Christmas season, a handful of retailers were forecasting continued gains.
Wal-Mart said it expects sales to rise in a range of 2 to 4 percent, but Ross Stores said it's looking at flat January sales after a 4 percent gain during the prior-year period.
|Saks Fifth Avenue||+12.1%|
|May Dept. Stores||-3.5|
December sales for key retailers
Five weeks ended Jan. 1a, (dollar amounts in millions)
|2004 sales||2003 sales||Total %chg.||Same-store %chg.|
|BJ's Wholesale Club||$924.4||$847.8||9.0||5.6|
|The Bon-Ton Stores||257.8||253.1||1.9||6.6|
|Dillard Dept. Stores||1,255.9||1,246.2||0.8||0.8|
|May Dept. Stores||2,844.1||2,517.3||13.0||(3.5)|
|Pier 1 Imports||289.6||300.2||(3.5)||(8.8)|
|Value City Department Stores||219.5||224.8||(2.4)||(2.4)|
|Saks Fifth Avenue Stores||397.6||348.2||14.2||12.1|
|Sears U.S. sales||3,840.6||3,933.2||(2.4)||(3.0)|
|Wal-Mart Stores Inc.||38,424.0||33,896.0||13.4||3.0|
YTD sales for major retailers
43 weeks year to date
|a Reporting periods vary from store to store.
b For the 18 weeks year to date.
|BJ's Wholesale Club||$6,724.2||$6,081.3||10.6||6.3|
|The Bon-Ton Stores||1,248.1||577.4||43.6||0.6|
|Dillard Dept. Stores||7,038.8||7,120.1||(1.1)||(1.1)|
|Family Dollar b||2,123.0||1,903.0||11.6||3.0|
|May Dept. Stores||13,633.1||12,627.1||8.0||(2.4)|
|Pier 1 Imports||1,661.7||1,613.1||3.0||(4.7)|
|Value City Department Stores||1,366.8||1,439.7||(5.1)||(5.0)|
|Saks Fifth Avenue Stores||2,545.9||2,251.7||13.1||11.4|
|Sears U.S. sales||25,012.8||25,711.9||(2.7)||(1.7)|
|Wal-Mart Stores Inc.||265,013.0||237,865.0||11.4||3.4|
Related Content By Author
Vegas Performing with PureCare's Lonnie Scheps