Value Retailers Win in June
July 16, 2007,
Stuck in the summer doldrums, same-store retail sales remained weak for a third straight month, with off-pricers doing most of the positive business in June and full-price department stores lagging far behind, all posting declines.
The only thing drawing consumers out were low prices, putting warehouse clubs and off-pricers in the catbird seat last month. The strongest performer in the HTT ranking was Sam's Club with a hefty 7.6% same-store increase, easily outperforming sibling Wal-Mart Stores with its better than expected 1.6% increase. Not far behind were Costco, up 6.0% and BJ's, up 5.3%.
But picking up the rear with a huge 18.1% drop in comps was The Bon Ton regional department store chain. Same-store sales in the Bon Ton-owned Carson's division slipped at a slower pace of 1.7%, while comps for the combined operations fell 8.0%. Acting as a drag, said Tony Bucina, vice chairman and president-merchandising, were home and furniture, "the weakest performing areas."
Kohl's found itself in an unaccustomed spot on the losers list, with comps falling off by 4.5%. Larry Montgomery, ceo, blamed a shift in the calendar, which pushed Memorial Day sales into the May retail month.
Department stores as a class fared poorly, with Gottschalks sliding by 4.3%, Macy's off by 2.7% and Penney down by 1.5%. And Macy's doesn't expect sales to improve any time soon, forecasting a 3% drop for July. That's going to take a toll on profits, which Macy's now says will come in lower than expected, in the range of 20 to 30 cents, weakening from an earlier forecast of 35 to 45 cents — excluding costs of integrating May stores into Macy's.
In a change in HTT's monthly ranking of same-store sales, Dollar General falls off the list. After being acquired by a buy-out group and taken private, this retailer no longer releases standard financial information. Taking its place this month is Duckwall-ALCO, a 106-year-old Midwest-Mountain regional chain that targets small, under-served communities, with 255 stores in 21 states.
Winners and Losers
Same-store sales % change
June Sales for Key Retailers
Five weeks ended July 7a(dollar amounts in millions)
|2007 Sales||2006 Sales||Total % Chg.||Same-Store % Chg.|
|a. Reporting periods vary from store to store.
b. Total sales include Carson's results, but same-store sales are for Bon-Ton alone.
c. for the 45 weeks year-to-date of Costco's fiscal year.
d. for the 45 weeks year-to-date of FamilyDollar's fiscal year.
|BJ's Wholesale Club||$886.8||$807.3||9.8%||5.3%|
|The Bon-Ton Stores b||$279.6||$304.2||(8.1)||(18.1)|
|Dillard Dept. Stores||$620.7||$622.8||(0.3)||(1.0)|
|Wal-Mart Stores Inc.||$35,811.0||$32,735.0||9.4||2.5|
|22 WEEKS YEAR-TO-DATEa|
|BJ's Wholesale Club||$3,608.9||$3,351.2||7.7%||3.4%|
|The Bon-Ton Stores b||$1,251.9||$1,098.3||14.0||(7.5)|
|Dillard Dept. Stores||$2,911.8||$2,994.1||(2.7)||(4.0)|
|Family Dollar d||$5,848.3||$5,433.9||5.0||1.0|
|Wal-Mart Stores Inc.||$151,686.0||$140,044.0||8.3||1.2|
Related Content By Author
1200 Suppliers are Ready for You at Intertextile Shanghai
Home & Textiles Today eDaily
Most Viewed Articles
See the August 2017 issue of Home & Textiles Today. In this issue, we look at the Top 50 Retailing Giants Report, plus Manufacturing: Made in the USA gaining ground; International: Portugal ramping up exports; New products: NY Now home textiles introductions; Outlook: Commentary from H&TT's editors; and Planning: Trade show calendar.